The U.S. Bicentennial quarter, struck to mark 1776–1976, is a common coin in many collections. While most are worth only face value, specific types, errors, and high-grade examples attract premiums. This guide explains which Bicentennial quarters command the highest prices in 2025 and how to identify them.
Why some Bicentennial quarters are valuable
Value depends on three main factors: rarity, condition, and collector demand. Even low-mintage varieties can be inexpensive if many survive in worn condition.
Errors and special issues often sell for more than typical circulation examples. Proof and high-grade mint state coins also bring premiums because collectors prize sharp details and original surfaces.
Top Bicentennial quarters worth the most in 2025
Experts typically point to four categories that attract the highest prices. These categories are consistent across auction records and dealer price lists.
- 40% Silver Proof 1976-S — The San Francisco proof struck in 40% silver is collectible for both silver content and proof quality.
- High-grade Mint State (MS65 and up) — Business strikes graded MS65 or higher show minimal wear and strong luster, increasing value.
- Certified Proofs in PR69–PR70 — Proof coins with deep cameo contrast and top grades are rare and sought after.
- Error and Variety Coins — Off-center strikes, broadstrikes, doubled dies, and struck-through errors can fetch strong premiums.
Silver proofs and their appeal
1976-S silver proofs were produced for collectors and contain silver in the composition, which provides a base melt value. In 2025, silver market changes influence minimum values, but collector interest determines premiums above melt.
Look for original proof packaging and certificates, which help buyers trust authenticity and grade.
High-grade business strikes
Most circulated Bicentennial quarters are worth only face value or a few dollars. However, business strikes graded MS66+ sell well because sharply struck, clean coins are scarce.
Grading by a major service (PCGS, NGC, or ANACS) provides buyer confidence and typically increases resale value.
Error coins and varieties
Error coins can be unpredictable in value. Strong, dramatic errors usually bring the best prices; minor blemishes do not.
Common valuable errors include heavy doubling, substantial off-center strikes, and large planchet defects. Consult a specialist before assuming an error coin is worth a lot.
How to identify valuable Bicentennial quarters
Follow a simple checklist when sorting coins. This helps prioritize pieces for grading or sale.
- Check the mint mark: D, S, or no mark (Philadelphia). San Francisco proofs often have more collector value.
- Examine for errors: look for doubling, misalignment, or missing design elements.
- Assess surface condition: avoid coins with heavy wear, scratches, or cleaning marks.
- Consider grading: professional grades of MS65+/PR69+ typically secure better prices.
Key dates and mint marks to note
All Bicentennial quarters are dated 1776–1976. There are no single-year 1976 business strikes from Philadelphia with a mint mark; Philadelphia struck quarters without a mint mark. San Francisco proofs bear an S, and Denver business strikes bear a D.
Mint mark matters mainly for proofs and collector issues; business-strike mint marks are very common and only matter when combined with exceptional grade or error status.
Buying, grading, and selling tips
If you find a promising Bicentennial quarter, consider submitting it to a reputable grading service. Grading and encapsulation can unlock value, especially for proofs and high-grade mint states.
When selling, use multiple channels: online auction houses, coin dealers, and local auctions. Get several opinions for rare or unusual errors before listing a price.
Real-world case study
A regional collector found a 1976-S Bicentennial quarter in an album that looked especially sharp. After sending the coin to a third-party grading service, it received a high proof grade with strong cameo contrast.
The graded coin sold at auction for a notable premium over typical silver proof prices because bidders trusted the grade and the coin’s visual appeal. This example shows how grading and presentation impact final sale prices.
The Bicentennial quarter design (Dr. William Cousins) was minted only for the 1975–1976 period and all quarters bear the dual date 1776–1976 regardless of the actual production year.
Practical examples and quick reference
- Typical circulated Bicentennial quarter: face value to a few dollars.
- Uncirculated (MS60–MS64): modest premium, often $5–$25 depending on eye appeal.
- High-grade MS65+ or PR69–PR70: significant premiums; collector demand drives final price.
- Error coins and rare varieties: value varies widely—get an expert opinion before selling.
Final checklist before selling or grading
- Document provenance and packaging if available.
- Compare recent auction results for similar grade and variety.
- Consult a trusted dealer or numismatic forum for a second opinion.
- Consider holding high-grade coins if silver prices or collector demand are rising.
Following these practical steps will help you separate everyday Bicentennial quarters from those that deserve grading and specialist attention. In 2025, the most valuable examples remain silver proofs, top-graded mint state coins, and clear error pieces—so focus on condition, certification, and documented rarity when assessing worth.
